Jason's Chad & Jeremy Archive
Home
US Releases
UK Releases
CD Releases
Rarities
Unreleased
Liners
Photos
Press Releases
Specials
Links



Of Cabbages and Kings: a review.

Sundazed wasn't happy to simply reissue Distant Shores in 2000. They weren't even happy to just do Before and After in 2002. They went for broke, and also reissued C&J's stunning 1967 concept album, thus putting all of Chad and Jeremy's original Columbia LPs on CD.

The first side of this LP features two acknowledged classics: "Rest In Peace" and "The Gentle Cold of Dawn". They're still there, and sound as good as they ever will in master tape stereo, but now you can hear them alongside such underappreciated numbers as "I'll Get Around to it When and If I Can", "Can I See You?" and the hillarious "Family Way", in which Jeremy puts in one of his best performances ever on vinyl, particularly on the ad-libs! One criticism I would make of the sound is completely unavoidable. The LP, because it was so complex, sometimes was made from a number of 'bounced-down' multi-track tapes of different instrumental backings. Sometimes (mostly on the LP intro), this shows through at particularly loud volume. To correct this would likely be completely impossible, as it's unlikely all the elements still exist for a completely new mix from scratch.

The second side of this LP has had an undeservedly bad reputation among some over the last 30+ years. Chad Stuart, ever the perfectionist, is usually the first to bash it. But those who have actually heard it generally love it, and if you haven't heard it on your own I urge you to ignore all those detractors and judge for yourself. Where they say it's ponderous, it's actually thoughtful. Where they say it's overlong, I say it creates an amazing ambience. Chad once said that "if I had my druthers, I'd take a razor blade to 'The Progress Suite'", but to do that would be a crime against his craft.

This album deserved a lot better than to have sunk into oblivion. Thirty-five years after the 'summer of love', it's clear that, beyond the sales figures, Chad and Jeremy kicked the snot out of their primary summer/fall 1967 competition. The Beatles Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band and the Rolling Stones Their Satanic Majesties Request sound dated and hollow today. Of Cabbages and Kings continues to sound as skilled, as relevant, and as thrilling as it did the day it was released. Ironically, its commercial failure secured its uniqueness, as Chad & Jeremy took a step back from this level of experimentation on 1968's The Ark.

The sound on this CD simply blows the LP away. The orignal LP was apparently a bit too long for 1960s vinyl, forcing the grooves to be placed a tad too close together. This, combined with the occasionally 'bounced down' backings made the music-to-noise ratio a bit imbalanced. Well, no more vinyl noise on this one, it's now restored to its album master quality. The 'bounce-down' tape hiss has also been significantly reduced, though it can't be completely eliminated. It primarily exists as a very low frequency rumble which can occassionally be heard at loud volumes. Several of these tracks have already made their way onto CD (on Sony/Legacy's Painted Dayglow Smile compilation), and they are in similar quality on this disc, so it's the tracks that haven't appeared on compact disc before that are the true revelations. Listening to "The Progress Suite" is a brand-new experience with this amount of fidelity, like hearing the LP again for the first time.

Now, on to the bonus tracks:

"Manners Maketh Man" - Batman fans rejoice! For those who have very carefully watched C&J's appearance on Batman, you might have noticed that when they arrive at the airport, someone turns on a gramophone to give them a rocking background to their press conference. That rocking background really is a C&J track (if you listen closely, you can just make out some of the words). It was the first track discarded, in late 1966, from what was to become Of Cabbages and Kings, and is basically a chastisement of the then-older generation for treating pop stars and icons of pop culture like they were circus freaks. A very biting track which points out that manners, not haircuts, make a mature adult. Jeremy gets an acting "job" on this one, as one of the rude 'adults'. This one is in a new stereo remix.

"Cautionary Tale" - The hidden gem of the set. This is Jeremy' jaunty children's tale which, with the final verse left off, was used as the bridge in "Imagination" on The Ark in 1968. Listening to "Cautionary Tale" struck me just how much a small change could totally change the meaning of the song. In "Imagination", this section works as a reminder of the pleasant aspect of imagination, but the fact that the poor kid "somehow could not follow" is tragic considering how "real" his imaginary fears are, to the point where he has to flee from part of his house because "it always knows when you are there". But in "Cautionary Tale", with its extra verse, and without the negativity of the verses from "Imagination", the lesson is that dreams come true, and that a child's imagination is a wonderful and powerful thing. This very cute (though very short) song is presented in stereo.

"The Gentle Cold of Dawn" (inst) - The backing track of this song, before orchestral or vocal overdubs. While interesting, and in beautiful stereo, I think this one was poorly chosen. I much rather would have had instrumental tracks for "Editorial" and "Epilogue", thus making the Progress Suite listenable both as instrumentals and in its original form. Oh well, I'll not turn it down!

"Rest In Peace" (single mix) - Here's the "Sister Marie" b-side version, cut down to three minutes from the original LP version. It's presented here in mono because to mix it to stereo would defy the point of presenting the single mix, since it is an edit of a unique mono mix, so it would have to be completely remade from scratch using the original elements to be in stereo. Some of those original elements apparently do not exist anymore, so mono it is! Why do I say it's a completely unique mix as well as an edit? There are several subtle differences from the other mix, most obvious, an orchestral miscue eight seconds in. Nice to have on CD, especially since the single it appeared on is so frightfully rare, and because some say "Rest In Peace" is a bit ponderous at six+ minutes. The sitar solo, however, is still mostly there!

"Painted Dayglow Smile" (single version) - Here's the original November 1967 single version of a track which, in a later longer mix, appeared on The Ark. There are several subtle mix differences on this one, and the screech which is present on the version on The Ark is faded down in an attempt to be more radio-friendly. This single mix is also still in mono, probably because it is a complicated mix, and would have been difficult (if not impossible) to remake from scratch. This rarity was released on CD on 1992's Painted Dayglow Smile compilation, but this is an excellent substitute for that now-rare disc.

"Sister Marie" (single version) - This is probably the rarest originally released Columbia track. It first appeared on a bomb 1968 single, and has never been reissued until now. On 1992's Painted Dayglow Smile CD an alternate version was released, removing all the cool 1968 phasing and special effects, as well as some backing vocals and musical parts. This one is still in mono, again probably because of how difficult it would be to remake this complex mix. Most fans have only ever heard the alternate, which although pleasant, is a very unimpressive contender for hit single. The actual single version, as presented here, is a fantastic and energetic record.

Overall, this CD is an excellent release, placing the LP side-by-side with a number of legendarily rare single tracks and some fascinating new finds. The love that Sundazed put into the reissue of this cult classic is obvious. The fact that it has taken until 2002 to restore this one to availability is perhaps a sign that sometimes labels save the best for last. Whether you've never been able to track down the rare vinyl of this, or you've loved it since the day it came out, this CD is a revelatory experience, and a vital piece of the Chad and Jeremy puzzle. This is definitely one that you can play and play.

Jason Rhoden

Click here to visit their Official Website.

Copyright 2007  Frank Jason Rhoden.